Broken link building and resource page links: process, cost and realistic results
Broken link building means finding dead links on relevant pages and offering your working page as the replacement. Resource page link building asks curators to list a useful, non-commercial page. Both are within Google's rules and limited by how many real opportunities exist.
In short
- Broken link building replaces a dead link on someone else's page with a link to your equivalent, working resource.
- Practitioners estimate $100 to $300 per earned link for broken link building and $50 to $200 in labour for a resource page link.
- Published success rates run from 2 to 10 percent of prospects and are poorly evidenced, so plan on the low end.
- The risk is R1, and first links usually arrive in two to six weeks.
Broken link building finds pages that link to something that no longer exists and offers your page as the replacement. Resource page link building is its close relative: you ask the curator of a “useful links” page to add yours. In both cases you are helping someone maintain a page they already care about, which is why the links are R1. Unless a source is named, the process and cost figures on this page are practitioner knowledge. Published success rates for these tactics are inconsistent, and we say so where it matters, because a reader who plans a quarter around a number from a blog post should know how thin the evidence behind that number is.
Why people use them and what they cost
The pitch gives the site owner something: a fix for a dead link, or a resource their readers will use. That changes the nature of the email. Most link requests ask a stranger for a favour, whereas this one points out a fault on their page and hands them the repair, so the person reading it has a reason of their own to act. No money changes hands, and nothing in it conflicts with Google’s spam policies. The links also tend to sit on pages that have been online for years and collected links of their own, which means the page you are added to usually has some standing before your link arrives.
The limit is supply. There are only so many dead resources and maintained link pages in any field, and no amount of effort creates more of them. A campaign in a field with a long history of public information, where organisations have published and retired guides for decades, can run for months. A campaign in a field that barely existed a few years ago may exhaust its prospects in an afternoon. This is the main reason the tactic supports a programme without being able to carry one, and it is worth checking how many real opportunities exist before any content is commissioned.
On cost, practitioners estimate about $100 to $300 per earned link for broken link building, covering the replacement content and the outreach. Resource page links come in at about $50 to $200 per link in labour, if the asset already exists. Both are practitioner estimates, and the gap between them is explained by the content. A broken link campaign usually has to build a page to stand in for the dead one, while a resource page pitch uses something you have already published, so most of its cost is the time spent finding and writing to curators. Expect two to six weeks from the first emails to the first live link, since curators of old pages do not check their inbox for link fixes every day.
Broken link building, step by step
The work runs in a fixed order, and the order matters because each step decides whether the next is worth doing. You start from the dead page and only build content once you know that enough sites still link to it.
- Find dead pages that still have links. Run a backlink tool’s broken backlinks report on competitor sites, or filter their most-linked pages to those returning a 404. Wikipedia’s dead link notices on articles in your field are another source.
- See what the page used to be. Open it in the Wayback Machine.
- Build the replacement. Recreate the resource or improve on it. It has to be an honest substitute for what the link originally pointed to.
- Export the pages that link to the dead URL.
- Email the right person. Give the exact location of the dead link and your replacement. Keep it short.
Practitioners suggest only pursuing a dead resource that had 20 or more referring domains. Below that, the content cost is hard to recover, and the arithmetic is easy to follow once you set it beside the conversion rates further down this page: if only a small share of the sites you write to make the change, a dead page with a handful of linking sites may not return a single link for the work of rebuilding it. The third step is where campaigns most often go wrong. Were a paint retailer to find a dead guide to preparing walls for painting, a proper replacement would be a guide to preparing walls for painting. A product category page with a paragraph about preparation on top is something else, and a curator who clicks through will see the difference at once.
Resource page link building
Resource page work follows a shorter path, because there is no dead page to reconstruct. It begins with search. Use operators such as intitle:resources, inurl:links or “helpful resources” with your topic, and expect to read a lot of pages that turn out to be abandoned. Then qualify each page. The practitioner rules of thumb are that it has been updated in the last two years, it lists fewer than 100 links, and it is on your topic. Each rule screens for a different failure. A page nobody has touched for years has no one to answer your email, a page with a very long list adds anything it is sent, and a page on another topic has no reason to include you.
The last step is to pitch a non-commercial resource: a guide, a tool, a dataset. Curators do not add product pages, because their page exists to help a reader and a sales page helps the seller. The best hosts are universities, libraries, public bodies and associations, which keep such pages as part of serving their own audience and tend to keep them for a long time. If you do not have an asset that fits, build one first: see linkable assets. Pitching a curator with nothing suitable to offer wastes the contact, and you may not get a second hearing from the same person once something better is ready.
What results to expect
Guides quote a conversion rate of 2 to 10 percent of prospects for broken link building. That is low-confidence evidence. Our research found success figures for classic outreach tactics ranging widely for the same method, with no large current dataset behind them. A range that wide is hard to plan with, since the top of it is five times the bottom, and the campaigns that get written up are more likely to be the ones that went well.
Broader outreach benchmarks give a sense of scale. BuzzStream measured a 3.59 percent reply rate across 51 million outreach emails in 2025, and Hunter’s outreach guide puts prospect-to-link conversion for standard link outreach at about 1.3 percent. Note that the first figure counts replies and the second counts links, so they describe different stages of the same funnel, and a reply is a long way from a live link. A broken link email offers a concrete fix, which is why practitioners expect it to beat a generic request. That expectation is reasonable, but it is an expectation, so plan on the low end until your own numbers say otherwise.
One follow-up helps. The Backlinko and Pitchbox study of 12 million emails, from 2019, found a single follow-up lifted replies by 65.8 percent. The study is several years old and covers outreach in general, so the size of the lift may differ for this tactic, but the direction makes sense for it. The person who maintains a links page is rarely waiting for your message, and a short reminder a few days later often reaches them at a moment when fixing the page takes less effort than ignoring you again.
How to judge the page and the risks
Not every link page is worth being on, and it is better to find that out before the outreach than after. Check that the page is indexed and gets some traffic or has links pointing at it, because a page Google has not kept or that nobody visits gives you little. Check that someone maintains it, which you can usually tell from whether its existing links still work. And check that it does not list everyone who asks. A page with hundreds of unrelated links is a link directory by another name, and low-quality directory links are named in Google’s link spam policy. Our guide to vetting a publisher has the full checklist.
There are no spam footprints in the honest version of either tactic, since each link is added by a person who looked at your page and judged it useful. Two things still deserve attention. The first is sender reputation. Templated mass emails get marked as spam and damage your sending domain, and the damage reaches every other email the business sends from it. Supply is limited in any case, so there is little to gain from sending the same message to a list of thousands.
The second is the grey variant. Some operators buy the expired domain behind a dead resource and redirect it to their own site to capture its links. From a distance it looks like a shortcut to the same result, yet nobody who linked to the old resource has agreed to anything. That is expired domain work, which Google added to its spam policies in March 2024, and it sits at a higher risk level than anything on this page.
Who it suits and when not to use it
These tactics suit education, health, public sector topics and technical fields, where old resource pages are common. Resource pages in particular also suit safety, financial literacy and local topics. What those fields have in common is a habit of pointing readers to further help, built up over many years, so there are both pages to be listed on and dead resources to replace. It is a poor fit for young commercial niches where such pages were never built, and no prospecting method will find pages that do not exist.
Skip these tactics if you have nothing non-commercial to offer, or if your field has few old resource pages. Skip them too if you have not yet fixed the broken links pointing at your own site. It makes little sense to write to strangers about dead links on their pages while links you already earned are pointing at your own missing pages. Link reclamation recovers links you already earned, costs less, and should come first.
Common questions
Does broken link building still work?
It works where old resource pages still exist, such as education, health and technical fields. It is limited by the number of dead resources worth replacing, so it will not carry a whole programme.
What is a good success rate for broken link building?
Guides quote 2 to 10 percent of prospects. Our research found figures for this tactic to be inconsistent and thinly evidenced, so treat that range as directional.
What is resource page link building?
You find curated pages of useful links on your topic and ask the curator to add a non-commercial resource of yours, such as a guide, tool or dataset.
How do I find broken links to replace?
Look for dead pages that still have backlinks, using a backlink tool's broken links report on competitor sites, and check lists of dead links on Wikipedia for your topic.
Vendors to look at


AhrefsSEO suite: Site Explorer backlink index, keywords, audit, rank tracking, Brand Radar
BuzzStreamOutreach CRM for link building and digital PR; ListIQ prospecting add-on
Hunter.ioEmail finder, verifier, domain search, basic cold email sequences

