How we review
This page explains what our reviews are based on, how the editor's rating is set and how risk is rated.
What a review is based on
Every review is written from the vendor's own public pages, its terms and third-party ratings on independent review platforms. Each review gives the date we checked them, and says so when a page could not be read or a fact is not published.
The editor's rating
Reviews show an editor's rating out of 10. It is the editor's own judgement of the vendor, based on its public pages and third-party ratings. It is an opinion and it is labelled as one wherever it appears.
The editor weighs five things when setting it:
- how openly the vendor publishes its prices
- the guarantee or terms it commits to in writing
- ratings on independent review platforms, and how many reviews stand behind them
- the size and coverage of what it offers
- track record, and how much the company discloses about itself
Editor's picks are vendors the editor recommends from professional experience, and their rating reflects that.
Risk
Risk is shown separately from the rating, on the R1 to R5 scale used across the site. A vendor can deliver exactly what it sells and still sell a risky method. On a review, the risk rating is the editor's judgement of that vendor. It starts from the rating of the tactic the vendor sells, which is R3 for paid placements, and can move one step for how the vendor works.
Money and independence
Some vendor links are affiliate links. Vendors cannot pay for a review or a rating. The order of a list is our choice. See the affiliate disclosure.
Corrections
Vendors can ask us to correct a factual error. We check the claim against a public source and update the page with a new date.

