How to track backlinks and measure what they do
Track every link you build for live status, indexation, attribute and anchor changes, and loss. Check weekly for the first three months, then monthly, and measure impact in batches against pages that received no links.
In short
- A link on a page Google has not indexed passes nothing, so check indexation at day 7, day 14 and day 30 after it goes live.
- Check live status, the rel attribute and the anchor weekly for the first three months, then monthly.
- Most SEOs expect a link to show an effect within one to three months, according to a March 2026 survey of 518 SEOs by Editorial.link, where 57.1% gave that answer.
- Attribution of a ranking change to a single link is weak. Measure batches of links against control pages that received none.
Building a link is half the job. Pages get deleted, attributes change to nofollow, articles slip out of the index and publishers sell out to link farms. If you do not check, you will report links that no longer exist, and you will go on paying vendors whose placements quietly fail. An Ahrefs study cited in our research found that about two thirds of links disappear over nine years. We have not re-checked that figure, so treat it as indicative, but the direction is enough to justify a routine. Tracking has two parts: confirming the link is still what you paid for or earned, and working out whether it did anything.
What to record for every link
Keep one row per link, in a tracker that everyone on the team uses, because every later check compares the page as it is now with what the row says it should be. The row starts with identity: a link ID, the campaign, the method and the vendor. Next comes the money, which means the cost, the currency, the order date, the guarantee end date and whether a replacement has been claimed. Then record where the link sits: the source URL, the source domain, the target URL and the placement in the page, whether body, bio or sidebar. The link details follow, namely the anchor, the rel value and whether the article is labelled as sponsored. These fields are the minimum, and each one answers a question that will come up later, such as whether a vendor still owes you a replacement or whether an anchor was changed after you approved it.
Three more groups complete the row. Publisher metrics cover DR, the organic traffic of the domain, the traffic of the page and the traffic country. Technical state covers the HTTP status, whether the page is indexed and on what date, and whether the canonical and robots settings are correct. Status covers the live date, the date last checked, the current status and any notes. Status should be one of live, lost, changed, noindexed or redirected, since a fixed set of values lets you count and filter without reading free text. Record who approved each link and keep the evidence, such as a screenshot and an archive snapshot from the day it went live. That evidence is what you send when a publisher says the link was never followed or the anchor was always different.
The first 48 hours
The first check happens before payment is released, because that is the moment you have most say over the outcome. Once the invoice is paid, a wrong anchor or a noindex tag becomes a favour you are asking for. Go through the following before you approve the placement.
- The URL is live, returns 200 and sits on the agreed domain and section.
- The link is present in the rendered page, with the correct target, anchor and rel value, and with no redirect chain.
- There is no noindex tag, the canonical is correct, and neither robots.txt nor an X-Robots-Tag header blocks the page.
- The page looks the same when fetched with a Googlebot user agent. A difference means cloaking.
- The article can be reached through internal links and is in the sitemap or a category page.
- No competitor or restricted-niche links have been added alongside yours.
If the link is missing or wrong, return it to the publisher and hold payment. Each item on the list covers a way a placement can look fine to a person and still be worthless to a search engine. A link that appears in the browser but is absent from the rendered page Googlebot receives, or an article that no other page on the site links to, will pass a casual glance and fail the purpose you paid for.
Checks, cadence and indexation
After the first check, the work becomes a schedule. The early weeks carry the most risk, so the checks start weekly and thin out once a link has settled.
| Check | How | How often |
|---|---|---|
| Live status: 200 response and link present in rendered page | Crawler or monitoring tool, plus a Googlebot user agent check | Weekly for three months, then monthly |
| Attribute change, such as followed to nofollow or sponsored | Monitoring tool comparison | Weekly |
| Anchor or target URL change | Comparison against the tracker | Weekly |
| Indexation of the source page | URL-level index check | Day 7, 14 and 30, then quarterly |
| Noindex, canonical, robots.txt, X-Robots-Tag | Crawler | With each live check |
| Page orphaned or archived, or outbound links multiplying | Manual sample | Quarterly |
| Publisher health: traffic collapse, deindexing, turned into a link farm | Traffic trend in Ahrefs or Semrush | Quarterly |
| Lost links across the whole profile | Lost links report in Ahrefs or Semrush, Search Console links export | Monthly |
| New unknown links, such as scrapers or negative SEO | Tool alerts | Weekly |
Indexation deserves separate attention, because a link on a page Google has not indexed passes nothing. Pages on weak sites often stay out of the index for weeks, or for good. The difficulty is that you cannot use Search Console to inspect a page on a site you do not own. You can search Google for the exact URL restricted to its site, or use a third-party index checker, and both are approximations. The Search Console links report on your own site is also only a sample of the links Google knows about, so a link missing from it has not necessarily been ignored.
A workable sequence when a page is not indexed runs as follows. Check on day 7, day 14 and day 30. If the page is still out on day 14, ask the publisher to link the article from a category page or the homepage and to include it in the sitemap, since both make the page easier for a crawler to find. On day 21, consider an indexing service, and only one that refunds URLs it fails to index. On day 45, claim a replacement or refund under the guarantee. Indexing services can prompt a crawl. They cannot make Google keep a poor page in the index, and our research found no independent large-sample test of them in 2026. If a paid placement needs an indexer at all, that tells you something about the publisher, and it is worth noting in the row before you order from the same site again.
When a link is lost or changed
When a check fails, the response should be set in advance, with a deadline, so that nobody has to decide from scratch while a guarantee period runs down.
| What happened | What to do | Deadline |
|---|---|---|
| Link not live or wrong at the first check | Return to the publisher or vendor and hold payment | 48 hours |
| Page not indexed at day 45 | Claim a replacement or refund | 7 days |
| Link removed, switched to nofollow, or page noindexed inside the guarantee | Claim a replacement and log a strike against the vendor | 7 days |
| Publisher’s traffic falls by more than 70%, or the site is deindexed | Stop buying from it and assess the links you already have | 14 days |
| Sudden spike of unknown links | Document it and watch rankings. Disavow only with evidence of harm | 72 hours |
These deadlines are a working standard for a team, not an industry rule. A common convention is that three strikes remove a vendor from the approved list. The value of writing them down is that a guarantee only helps if someone claims on it in time, and a claim is far easier to make when the tracker already holds the order date, the guarantee end date and the evidence from the day the link went live. For an earned link the route is different, because there is nothing to claim: ask the editor politely whether it can be restored.
The checks themselves can be automated with a range of tools. Ahrefs and Semrush both report new and lost links and send alerts. Majestic, Linkody, Monitor Backlinks, LinkChecker Pro, Linkbox and BacklinkManager are dedicated monitors. WhitePress includes a backlink manager that monitors orders placed through its marketplace. Screaming Frog in list mode, with custom extraction, will check a list of source URLs for your link. Our SE Ranking desk review covers its backlink tracker. We could not verify current pricing for the dedicated monitors, so check it before you choose.
Measuring impact
Knowing that a link is live tells you nothing about whether it helped, and that second question is harder. At page level, watch rankings and clicks for the keyword group of the target URL over the 4 to 12 weeks after the linking page is indexed. Annotate the live dates in your rank tracker and Search Console exports, and compare against control pages that received no links in the same period. The timing matches what practitioners expect: in a March 2026 survey of 518 SEOs by Editorial.link, 57.1% said a link shows an effect within one to three months and 33% said three to six. Measure from the date the linking page is indexed, not from the date you paid. At domain level, track growth in referring domains against competitors, the share of links going to commercial against informational pages, and the anchor mix.
In business terms, track organic revenue per target page. A useful figure is cost per incremental organic click: link spend divided by the extra clicks gained over 12 months. As a ceiling, BuzzStream suggests a cap on what a link campaign is worth: the monthly traffic value of the target keywords multiplied by 24 months. Links also show up in AI answers now. Brand mentions and citations in AI assistants can be tracked with tools such as Ahrefs Brand Radar and the Semrush AI toolkit, and in BuzzStream’s State of Digital PR 2026 survey, 55.4% of digital PRs reported AI citations as a success measure.
The caveat is that you can rarely pin a ranking change on one link. Other links, content changes and Google updates all move at the same time, so a page that rose after a placement may have risen anyway. Judge batches, not single placements, and use the control pages to see how much of the movement happened across the site regardless of links. That discipline carries into reporting. Report unique referring domains, not raw links. Exclude syndicated copies of the same article. Show nofollow links and unlinked mentions separately. Never report DR on its own. Add durability: the share of links still live and indexed at 90 and 365 days. A durability figure is the one number in the report that comes straight from the tracking described above, and it tells a budget holder how much of last year’s spend is still working.
Where to go next
The roles that own these checks are set out in link building team roles and KPIs, which is the place to settle who runs the weekly crawl and who chases a vendor. For the rules on strikes, guarantees and escalation, see link buying policy and governance.
Common questions
How do I check if a backlink is still live?
Load the page and confirm it returns a 200 status and that the link is present in the rendered page, with the right target and rel attribute. A crawler or monitoring tool can do this on a schedule. Repeat the check with a Googlebot user agent to catch cloaking.
How do I know if a backlink is indexed?
Search Google for the exact URL restricted to its own site, or use a URL-level index checker. Both are approximations, because you cannot inspect a page in Search Console unless you own the site.
How long does a backlink take to work?
In Editorial.link's 2026 survey, 57.1% of SEOs said one to three months and 33% said three to six. Measure from the date the linking page is indexed, not from the date you paid.
What should I do when a link is removed?
If it was a paid placement inside its guarantee period, claim a replacement from the publisher or vendor within a week and log the incident. If it was earned, ask the editor politely whether it can be restored.

