How a link building campaign runs, from prospect list to live link

A link building campaign runs in a fixed order. Set the goal and target pages, build and vet a prospect list, find contacts, pitch and follow up, agree terms, check the live link and track it. Each step has a number you can measure.

In short

  • A campaign has ten steps, and the two checks that sit before and after publication are the ones most often skipped.
  • Reply rates for link outreach run from about 3.5% to 8.5% in published datasets, and Hunter's outreach guide, updated in April 2026, reports about 1.3% of prospects becoming links.
  • The Backlinko and Pitchbox study of 12 million emails in 2019 found that one follow-up raised replies by 65.8%.
  • A link is not finished when it goes live. Check indexing at day 7, 14 and 30 and log the result.

A link building campaign is a sequence of ten steps: goal, prospect list, vetting, contacts, sending setup, pitch, follow-up, terms and content, live checks, and tracking. The order matters, because each step filters the work of the next one. Skip vetting and you pitch link farms. Skip the live check and you report links that Google cannot see. The steps that get skipped are the ones that produce nothing visible at the time, which is why this lesson gives them as much room as the pitch.

This lesson describes one campaign built on outreach. The same gates apply if you buy placements, with a purchase in place of a pitch, so the vetting, the written terms, the checks and the tracking all carry over unchanged. What follows is the whole sequence in one table, then each group of steps in turn, with the figures that tell you what to expect and the links to the lessons that cover each step in depth.

The ten steps at a glance

Step What you do What you measure
1. Goal Pick target pages, a link reason and a budget Links needed per page
2. Prospect Build the list of sites and pages Prospects added
3. Vet Remove weak and irrelevant sites Share of list rejected
4. Contacts Find and verify an address per prospect Bounce rate
5. Setup Prepare the sending domain and mailbox Spam complaint rate
6. Pitch Send by tier, personalised Reply rate
7. Follow up One or two reminders Positive reply rate
8. Agree Terms, content, anchor, target URL Conversion to link
9. Check Quality checks before and after publication Share passing first time
10. Track Log, check indexing, report Live and indexed at 90 days

The right-hand column is the reason to lay the campaign out this way. Each step has its own measure, so when the result at the end is poor you can see which step lost the links. A campaign that only counts links won cannot tell a weak list from a weak pitch or a pitch that worked from a placement that was never indexed.

Steps 1 to 5: goal, list, vetting, contacts and setup

Start with the pages that need links and the reason anyone would link to them. One campaign should have one link reason, such as a data study to cite or broken links to replace, because the reason shapes both the list and the email. If the reason changes halfway down the list, the email has to become general enough to cover both, and a general email is the kind that gets ignored.

Then build the list and cut it. Link prospecting explains the sources. Vetting is where most of the list should go: BuzzStream’s June 2026 study rated 96.2% of roughly 257,000 guest post sellers as low quality. That figure describes sites that sell guest posts, not every site on the web, but it is a fair warning about what a raw list contains if any of it came from “write for us” searches or seller lists. Record a score or a pass and fail note for every site, using the method in how to vet a publisher. A high share of the list rejected at this step is the step doing its job, since every site removed here is an address you do not pay to find and an email you do not send.

Next, find the person who can edit the page and verify the address, as set out in finding contacts and verifying emails. The measure for this step is the bounce rate, and it is only known after sending, which is why verification has to happen before.

Sending setup is easy to skip and expensive to get wrong. The usual practice among outreach teams is a separate domain or subdomain for outreach, with SPF, DKIM and DMARC records in place, a warm-up period of two to four weeks, and 30 to 50 sends per mailbox per day. These are working methods, not published rules. The hard limit that is published comes from the mailbox providers: since February 2024 Google and Yahoo have required bulk senders to keep spam complaints under 0.3%. The warm-up is the part that catches first campaigns out, because it has to start weeks before the first real email, at a point when the list is not yet finished and the pitch is not yet written.

Steps 6 to 8: pitch, follow up and agree terms

A pitch needs three things: one line that proves you read the page, the exact place the link would go, and the benefit to the reader. Link outreach emails has the detail. Expect low numbers. The Backlinko and Pitchbox study of 12 million emails, published in 2019, found an 8.5% reply rate. BuzzStream’s 2025 platform data across 51 million emails is reported at 3.59%. Hunter’s outreach guide, updated in April 2026, reports that about 1.3% of prospects end as a link. The three figures come from different samples and measure different things, two of them replies and one of them links, so they should not be combined. What they share is their size: each one says that the large majority of prospects end without a reply or a link, and a plan has to be built on that.

Two findings from the 2019 study still shape practice. A personalised email body raised replies by 32.7%, and a single follow-up raised them by 65.8%. Send one or two follow-ups, three to five working days apart, each with something new. More than two invites spam complaints, and with the complaint limit at 0.3% there is very little room for them. Volume does not rescue a weak pitch either. BuzzStream’s April 2025 analysis of 31 million emails found that campaigns of 1,001 to 5,000 emails had a reply rate 68% lower than campaigns of 1 to 50. So the response to a low reply rate is to go back to the list and the reason, and sending the same email to more people makes the rate worse.

Replies fall into four groups: yes, no, a request for something in return, and a price. The third is common and often reasonable, such as a quote, a better resource or a share in your newsletter. The fourth needs a decision that belongs to policy, not to the person sending emails, because a price offered in the middle of a campaign is easy to accept without anyone having agreed that the site may buy links at all. See what to do when a site asks for money.

When a placement involves new content, write down the target URL, the anchor text, the link attribute and any labelling before work starts. A placement brief holds all of it on one page. For a guest post, the editor’s guidelines come first and your brief second. Writing the terms down at this point is what makes the checks in the next step possible, since a link can only be checked against something that was agreed.

Step 9: checks before and after publication

Two gates catch most problems, one before the piece goes live and one just after. Before publication, five things should be true. The publisher’s vetting result is recorded and above your threshold. The target URL returns a 200 status, is indexable and has the correct canonical. The anchor is within your policy. The draft is accurate and carries no competitor link. And any price and terms are confirmed in writing. Most of these are checks on your own side, which is the point of the first gate: it stops you sending a publisher a link to a page of yours that is broken or redirected.

The second gate runs after publication, within two days, and it is a checklist to tick off against the live page:

  • The page is live on the agreed domain and section.
  • The link is in the rendered page, points to the right URL and has the agreed attribute.
  • The page is not set to noindex, is not blocked in robots.txt and has a correct canonical.
  • The page looks the same when fetched with a Googlebot user agent.
  • The article can be reached through the site’s own navigation.
  • A screenshot and an archive copy are saved.

If the link is wrong or missing, return it to the publisher and hold any payment. A 48-hour deadline for that is a sensible house rule. The checks on noindex, robots.txt, the Googlebot fetch and navigation all ask the same question from different sides, which is whether Google can find and read the page the link sits on. A link that a visitor can see but Google cannot reach is the case this gate exists to catch, and the screenshot and archive copy are what you will rely on if the page is changed later.

Step 10: track, index and report

Log every link with its date, source page, target, anchor, attribute and cost. Then check that Google has indexed the page, because a link on an unindexed page passes nothing. A standard routine is to check at day 7, 14 and 30, ask the publisher for an internal link at day 14, and treat day 45 as the point to ask for a replacement. The request for an internal link is the practical remedy at the midpoint: it gives Google a path to the page from elsewhere on the publisher’s site. How to track backlinks covers the tools.

Report on four levels: input (prospects, pitches, spend), process (reply rate, conversion), output (new referring domains, links to priority pages, cost per link) and durability (share still live and indexed at 90 and 365 days). The last level is the easiest to leave out, and it changes the others. A cost per link worked out on the day of publication counts every link, including the ones that will be removed or never indexed, so the honest figure is the cost per link that is still live and indexed when you check again.

How long it takes and where to go next

The time from first contact to a live link is the middle of the process only. Add time for list building, vetting and warm-up at the front and for indexing checks at the back. Four to eight weeks for a first full campaign is a reasonable working estimate, not a measured figure. The warm-up of two to four weeks alone accounts for a large part of that, which is why it pays to start the sending setup on the first day and build the list while the mailbox warms.

Run one small campaign end to end before scaling. A small run shows you your own numbers for each row of the table, and those are a better basis for the next budget than any published average. If you plan to use a platform to manage the steps, the outreach tools comparison lists the options. Terms such as referring domain and canonical are in the glossary.

Common questions

What are the steps of a link building campaign?

Set a goal and target pages, build a prospect list, vet it, find contacts, set up sending, pitch, follow up, agree terms and content, check the live link, then track and report.

How long does a link building campaign take?

A full campaign, from list building to reporting, usually runs four to eight weeks as a working estimate. No dated study of the time from first email to live link was found.

How many follow-up emails should I send?

One or two, a few working days apart, each adding something new. More than two risks spam complaints that harm your sender reputation.

What should I measure in a link building campaign?

Measure each stage. Prospects added, bounce rate, reply rate, links won, cost per link, and whether links are still live and indexed after 90 days.

Do I need special software to run a campaign?

No. A backlink tool, a spreadsheet and a mailbox are enough for a first campaign. Outreach platforms save time once you send a few hundred emails a month.

Vendors to look at

  • BazoomEditor's pick

    Sponsored content and link marketplace, managed service

  • MotherlinkEditor's pick

    Backlink services, guest posts, niche edits, full SEO