How to build a media list that is relevant
Build a media list from the story outwards. Find the journalists who covered the topic in the last 60 days, check each one by hand, split the list into segments with their own angle, and keep it small. Relevance, not size, decides the reply rate.
In short
- Cision's State of the Media 2026 found that 72% of journalists named irrelevant pitches as the top reason for blocking a sender, so a careless list costs you future campaigns as well as this one.
- BuzzStream's April 2025 analysis of 31 million emails found a 1.15% reply rate for campaigns of 1 to 50 emails and 0.37% for campaigns of 1,001 to 5,000.
- A working norm is 50 to 300 journalists per campaign, each checked against an article published in the last 60 days.
- In BuzzStream's State of Digital PR 2026, 62.8% of practitioners named outdated journalist data as their main problem with tools.
- Journalists who have replied before answer 20.1% of pitches against 1.06% for cold contacts, according to BuzzStream's April 2026 data, so past contacts belong at the top of every list.
A media list is the set of journalists you will pitch one story to. Build it from the story outwards: find the people who have written about this exact topic recently, check each one by hand, group them by the angle they will care about, and stop when you run out of people who fit. A list of 80 relevant names does better than a list of 2,000. That sounds like a matter of taste until you look at what journalists say about the pitches they receive and at what happens to email sent in bulk, so the numbers come first here and the method follows.
Why relevance decides everything
Cision’s State of the Media 2026 surveyed 1,899 journalists. It found that 72% consider a quarter or fewer of the pitches they receive relevant, that 82% reject pitches that do not fit their audience or beat, and that 72% named irrelevant material as the top reason for blocking a sender. The last figure is the one that should change how a list is built. A pitch that misses can end with your address blocked, which means every off-target name on a list is a journalist you may not reach next time, when you have a story that does suit them.
Sending data says the same. BuzzStream’s April 2025 analysis of 31 million emails in 86,000 campaigns compared campaigns of different sizes:
| Campaign size | Open rate | Reply rate |
|---|---|---|
| All campaigns | 33.79% | 0.85% |
| 1 to 50 emails | 35.42% | 1.15% |
| 1,001 to 5,000 emails | 29.76% | 0.37% |
Mass campaigns also earned 70% fewer links than campaigns of 51 to 100 emails. Read the table from top to bottom and the pattern is plain: as the send grows, fewer people open the email and far fewer reply, with the reply rate for the largest campaigns (0.37%) at about a third of the rate for the smallest (1.15%). Bigger lists get fewer replies per email and fewer links in total. One plausible reason is the one the Cision survey points to, since a list can only reach thousands of names by including people whose beat does not match the story.
Start from the story, then look for names
Before looking for names, write down three things: the headline, the kind of reader who cares, and the kinds of publication that serve that reader. A study of rental prices by city suits personal finance desks, property trade titles and local news in each city. It does not suit “business journalists” in general. This step also tests the idea, because if you cannot name the beats, the story has no audience, and it is cheaper to learn that now than after the research is finished. The lesson on digital PR ideation covers that test in more detail.
With the beats written down, use more than one route to find the people, because each misses some. News search is the first: search the topic and its nearest synonyms in news results, limited to recent months, and the bylines are your first list. This costs nothing and is the most reliable test of who covers the subject now. Coverage of similar stories is the second route. Find who wrote about a comparable study or a competitor’s campaign, and use a backlink tool to see which articles linked to it. Our link gap analysis lesson explains the method. Your own history is a third source, meaning anyone who has covered or replied to you before, and social profiles and request hashtags are a fourth, since journalists state their beat in their profile and post what they are working on.
Media databases are the route most teams pay for. In BuzzStream’s State of Digital PR 2026, 46.6% of practitioners said they use Muck Rack and 44.6% use BuzzStream for list building. Roxhill, Vuelio and Prowly are other named options. Search by beat and keyword, then check what comes back, because a database is a starting point. In the same BuzzStream report, 62.8% of practitioners named outdated journalist data as their main tool problem. That is easy to understand once you remember that journalists change beats and employers often, so a record that was right when it was entered may now describe a different job.
Check every contact by hand
The working rule among practitioners is to verify each journalist against an article published in the last 60 days. It is slow, and it is the step that separates a list from an export. For each name, confirm five things.
- They still write for that outlet. Open their author page.
- They covered this topic recently. Find the article and save its URL.
- They use outside data or comment. Some writers only produce opinion or reviews.
- Their preferred contact route. Cision’s 2026 survey found that 97% of journalists prefer email.
- The outlet is worth being in. It should be a real news or trade site with editorial staff, its own audience and indexed articles. The checks in how to vet a publisher apply here too.
Muck Rack’s State of Journalism 2026, as relayed in secondary summaries we could not verify against the original, found that beat relevance was the quality journalists valued most in a pitch, at 70%. The saved article from step 2 is your proof of relevance, and it gives you an honest first line for the email. A pitch that opens by naming the piece the journalist wrote last month, and says why this story follows from it, shows in one sentence that the sender has done the checking. Without the saved article the only option is a generic opening, and a generic opening is what the mass sends in the BuzzStream table look like from the receiving end.
Segment the list and decide its size
One list with one email is the mass send that the data argues against. Split the list into segments, each with its own angle and subject line. The segments below are a working template.
| Segment | Who is in it | What they need from you |
|---|---|---|
| National news and consumer desks | Reporters on the main beat, such as money, health or travel | The headline finding and a named expert |
| Trade and specialist press | Editors and writers for the industry | The detail, the method and what it means for the sector |
| Regional and local press | Reporters by city or region | The figure for their area, in the subject line |
| Past contacts | Anyone who has replied or covered you before | An early, personal note |
Regional segments are where a data campaign multiplies. One table with a row per city gives each local outlet its own story, so a single piece of research becomes as many pitches as there are places in the data. That only works if the data has sound regional cuts, which data-led campaigns covers, because a local reporter who is sent a figure for their city will want to know how many records sit behind it.
Past contacts come first. BuzzStream’s April 2026 study of 1.32 million emails from 17 agencies found a reply rate of 20.1% for journalists who had replied before, against 1.06% for cold contacts. Those reached within 90 days of an earlier reply were about 30 times more likely to respond. A gap of that size is why the people who already know you belong at the top of every list and should hear about the story early, in a note written for them.
On size, practitioner workflows put a campaign list at 50 to 300 journalists. That is a norm, not a measured optimum. The BuzzStream figures suggest thinking in segments of up to about 50 to 100, each sent as its own small campaign, so that a list near the top of the range is really several small sends with different angles. If you cannot find 50 journalists who fit, pitch the ones you have with more care. If you have 500, your definition of “fit” is probably too loose, and the 60-day check will show which names to cut.
What to record
Keep the list where the whole team can see it, so a journalist is never pitched twice by two colleagues. Each entry needs the journalist’s name, outlet, role and beat, along with the work email and where it was found. Record the recent article that shows the fit, with its date, and the segment and angle you have assigned. Add the country and language, which matter as soon as a campaign crosses a border. Then keep the history of past contact: whether the person was pitched, replied, covered the story or asked not to be contacted, with notes on any preferences they have stated. The history is the part that pays back over time, since it is the only way to know who counts as a warm contact when the next campaign starts.
Journalists’ details are personal data. Keep only what you need, respect a request to be removed, and follow data protection law where you and they are based. Outreach platforms hold the list, the sending and the history together, which makes it easier to see at a glance who has been contacted and by whom. Our BuzzStream desk review describes one, and the outreach tools comparison lists others.
Common mistakes and where to go next
The mistakes are mostly shortcuts around the steps above. The first is exporting a database search and sending to all of it, which skips the checking and produces the kind of large send that the BuzzStream figures show performing worst. The second is choosing outlets by authority score and ignoring the beat, so that the list is full of strong sites whose writers have no reason to cover the story. Pitching an editor-in-chief when a reporter covers the topic is another, as is adding every journalist at a publication when one of them is the obvious fit. Reusing last year’s list unchecked brings back the outdated data problem, since some of those people will have moved. Losing track of who asked not to be contacted is the last, and it means pitching someone who has already said no.
With the list built, write the email: how to pitch journalists covers what the surveys say they want. The digital PR tactic page puts the list in the context of a full campaign. Terms are defined in the glossary.
Common questions
How many journalists should be on a media list?
A working norm is 50 to 300 for a campaign, split into smaller segments. BuzzStream's 2025 data shows sends of 1 to 50 emails get the best reply rate, so many small targeted sends beat one large one.
Do I need a media database to build a list?
No, but it saves time. You can build a list by searching news results for recent articles on the topic. Databases still need checking, because 62.8% of digital PRs in BuzzStream's 2026 report complained of outdated journalist data.
How do I find a journalist's email address?
Start with the author page, the publication's contact page and the journalist's own social profiles. Media databases and outreach tools supply addresses too. Use work addresses, and keep to data protection law in your country.
How often should I update a media list?
Check every contact before each campaign. Journalists change beats and employers often, and a contact that was right six months ago may now cover something else.
Should I pitch more than one journalist at the same publication?
Usually pitch the one whose beat fits best. If you approach a second, choose a different desk and a different angle, and never send the same email to a whole newsroom.

