How to write a reconsideration request after a link penalty

A reconsideration request for an unnatural links manual action must do three things that Google asks for. Explain the exact issue, describe the steps you took to fix it, and document the outcome. Write it only after the links are removed or disavowed.

In short

  • Google's Manual Actions help page says a good request explains the exact quality issue, describes the steps taken to fix it and documents the outcome.
  • Google asks for documentation of the links you had removed and an explanation of any links you could not remove.
  • Most reviews take several days or weeks, and Google's help page says link-related requests may take longer.
  • A reconsideration request applies only to manual actions shown in Search Console. There is nothing to submit for algorithmic devaluation.
  • A lifted action rarely restores old rankings in full, because the links that supported them no longer count.

A reconsideration request is a short, factual document. Google’s Manual Actions help page, as checked in October 2026, says a good request does three things: it explains the exact quality issue on your site, describes the steps you have taken to fix it, and documents the outcome of your efforts. For unnatural links, that means showing which links broke the rules, what you removed, and what you disavowed and why. Write the request last. The work it describes has to be finished first, and most of this lesson is about that work, because the letter itself is the small part and the audit, the removal emails and the records behind it are the large one.

Check that a request applies to you

A reconsideration request exists only for manual actions. Open the Manual Actions report in Search Console. If it shows “Unnatural links to your site”, it will also say whether the action affects the whole site or part of it. If the report is empty, do not look for a form to fill in. Rankings lost because algorithms now ignore certain links cannot be appealed, because nothing has been applied that could be lifted. Link penalties and recovery explains how to tell the two cases apart, and it is worth being sure before you start, since the whole process below assumes a reviewer is waiting at the other end.

There are three situations in which you should not file. Do not file without a manual action. Do not file for a domain you intend to abandon, which is common for disposable sites in high-risk markets. And do not follow this process if the action is “Unnatural links from your site”: that one concerns links you sell or place on your own pages. The fix is on your site, not in your backlink profile, and Google’s help page asks you to remove or qualify those links before you select Request Review. The scope shown in the report matters for the same reason. It tells you whether the audit has to cover the whole profile or the part of the site the action names.

Do the work first

Google’s help page sets out the steps for this manual action. In summary, they run in this order.

  1. Download the list of links to your site from Search Console.
  2. Check the list for links that break Google’s link spam policy. If the list is large, start with the sites that link to you most and with links created in the last few months.
  3. Contact the owners of those sites and ask them to remove the links or stop them passing credit, for example with a nofollow attribute.
  4. Use the disavow tool for links you could not get removed.
  5. Select Request Review.

The order carries a message of its own: removal requests come before the disavow tool, and the review comes last. Search Console’s list is not complete, so most audits add exports from one or two backlink tools. Backlink audit and toxic links covers how to classify what you find. The usual groups are paid placements, private network links, large-scale guest posts with keyword anchors, widget and sitewide links, and comment or forum spam. Sorting links into these groups early pays off later, because the request has to say what kind of links were built, and a classified list answers that directly.

Stop all link buying while this is in progress. A request that describes a clean-up while new paid links appear will fail. So the instruction to stop has to reach everyone who can commission a link, including any agency still working on the account.

Keep evidence as you go, and build the disavow file

The request is only as strong as your records. Keep a spreadsheet with one row per linking domain. Each row should record the linking domain and an example URL, so the reviewer can see where the link is. It should give the type of link: paid, network, guest post, widget, comment or other. It should give the origin, meaning which vendor, campaign or employee created it, if known. It should list the contact attempts, with the dates of each email or form submission, and the result: removed, nofollowed, no reply, refused or asked for payment. The final column is the final status, which is either removed or in the disavow file.

Two or three contact attempts, a week or so apart, is the usual practice. That is a working method, not a number Google states. If a site demands money to remove a link, note it and disavow the domain. Put the spreadsheet in a shared document that anyone with the link can view, so a reviewer can open it. Filling the sheet in as the work happens is far easier than rebuilding it at the end from an inbox, and a record with dates in it is more convincing than a summary written from memory.

The disavow file comes out of the same sheet. List what you could not remove. Disavow at domain level, using the format domain:example.com, for sites that exist to sell or pass links, so that every page on them is covered. Add comment lines that say why groups of domains are included. Be careful with scope. Google’s John Mueller said in September 2026 that the tool “does have effects”. Disavowing good links removes their value. Include the links that break the policy and leave the rest, even if a tool has marked some of the rest with an alarming score, because the manual action is about links that break the policy and the file should match it.

What the request should contain

Google’s page names three elements. The structure below covers them and adds a fourth that reviewers look for in practice, which is how you will prevent a repeat. The first element is what happened. State plainly what kind of links were built, over what period, and by whom. If an agency did it, say so and say the contract has ended. If you bought links yourself, say that. Reviewers see evasive requests every day, so a plain admission is the quickest way to be taken seriously.

The second element is what you did, and here you should give numbers: how many linking domains you reviewed, how many you judged to break the policy, how many site owners you contacted, how many links were removed or changed to nofollow, and how many domains are in the disavow file. Link to the spreadsheet. The third element is what remains and why. Google asks specifically for “an explanation of any links you were unable to remove”. Say that owners did not reply, refused or asked for payment, and that those domains are disavowed. The fourth is what changes from now. Describe what stops this recurring: the vendor is gone, paid placements now carry a sponsored attribute, a named person approves link work, a written policy exists. Link buying policy and governance gives a structure for that policy.

As for the layout, use your own words and your own figures. What follows shows the order, not text to copy. Open with one sentence naming the manual action and its scope, then two or three sentences on how the links came about. Next comes the audit: sources used, total domains reviewed and the number found to break the policy. After that, the removal work: number contacted, number removed and number changed to nofollow, with a link to the evidence. Then the disavow file, with the date uploaded, the number of domains and why they could not be removed. Close with the changes to how the business handles links, and a named person and their role. Keep it to what a reviewer can verify. A few hundred words with evidence is better than a long apology.

Common mistakes

The same few mistakes come up again and again, and each of them is something a reviewer can see. Submitting before the work is done is the first. A disavow file uploaded the same morning with no removal effort looks like a shortcut. Relying on the disavow file only is the second, and it fails for a related reason: Google’s steps put removal requests before the disavow tool. Vague language is the third. “We cleaned up some low-quality links” tells the reviewer nothing, whereas the counts described above give them something to check.

Blaming without fixing is another. Naming a previous agency is fine. It does not replace the clean-up, because the action sits on your site whoever built the links. Reviewing only a sample is a mistake of scope: if the action is sitewide, the audit must cover the whole profile. Resubmitting unchanged is a mistake of persistence, since a second request needs more work behind it than the first. The last is continuing the tactic. New paid links during the review undo the request, which is the reason for the instruction earlier to stop all buying before the work starts.

What happens next

Google’s help page says most reviews take several days or weeks, and that link-related requests may take longer. You receive a confirmation message when you send the request, telling you the review is in progress. Google asks you not to resubmit before you have a decision on an outstanding request. If it is rejected, the action stays. Go deeper: older links, more link types, a wider disavow file, more removal attempts. Then submit again with the new figures. The response to a rejection is more of the same work across a wider part of the profile, with the records to show for it.

If it is accepted, the manual action is removed. Do not expect the old rankings back in full. The links that held them up have been removed or disavowed, so the pages now rank on what is left. Mueller said in September 2026 that recovery “can take quite some time, sometimes many months”. Replacing lost links with earned ones is the real recovery, and digital PR and link reclamation are the usual starting points.

If you need software for the audit, see the backlink tools comparison. To understand why the action was applied, read how Google detects paid links. Terms such as manual action and disavow are defined in the glossary.

Common questions

What is a reconsideration request?

It is a request for Google to review your site after you fix the problems named in a manual action. You submit it with the Request Review button in the Manual Actions report in Search Console.

How long does a reconsideration request take?

Google's help page says most reviews take several days or weeks, and that link-related requests may take longer. You receive a message when the review is complete.

Can I submit a reconsideration request without a manual action?

No. If the Manual Actions report shows no issue, there is nothing to review. A ranking drop caused by links being ignored by algorithms cannot be appealed.

Do I have to remove links or is a disavow file enough?

Google's steps ask you to contact site owners first and to disavow only the links you could not get removed. A request that shows no removal effort is weaker than one that documents it.

What happens if my reconsideration request is rejected?

The manual action stays. Review more links, extend the removal and disavow work, and submit again with the new evidence. Do not resubmit the same request.

Vendors to look at

  • BazoomEditor's pick

    Sponsored content and link marketplace, managed service

  • MotherlinkEditor's pick

    Backlink services, guest posts, niche edits, full SEO