How to get into third-party "best X" lists

You get into a "best X" list by finding the lists that search engines and AI assistants already retrieve for your category, then giving each editor a reason and the facts to include you. A few placements in lists that are cited beat many in lists nobody reads.

In short

  • Holding the top rank in a cited listicle lifted brand visibility by 16.5 percentage points in B2B software in Peec AI's research from September 2025 to March 2026, which is vendor data and correlational.
  • Peec AI's advice from the same research is that five strong placements in lists AI engines retrieve matter more than 50 placements in articles engines never see.
  • Lists in which a brand ranks itself first made up about 11% of AI citations in Peec AI's sample of 13,000 software listicles from December 2025 to February 2026.
  • In BuzzStream's State of Digital PR 2026 survey, 80% of digital PRs said they never pay for placements, down from 87.3% in 2025.
  • Law-firm summaries of the US Federal Trade Commission's 2023 Endorsement Guides say the FTC treats paid positions on a ranking site that presents itself as independent as deceptive.

To get into a “best X” list you need to do three things: find the lists that are retrieved for your category, work out how each one picks its entries, and give the editor a reason and the facts to add you. Most brands skip the first step and chase every list they can find. The evidence says a handful of the right ones is what counts. This lesson covers lists published by someone else. Lists you publish about yourself are a different thing with a different risk, covered near the end.

Why these lists matter

A “best project management tools” article puts your brand next to your category and your competitors in one document. That has always sent referral traffic, because a reader who opens such a list is close to choosing. It now also feeds AI answers, because comparison lists are what assistants retrieve when someone asks for a recommendation. Peec AI’s 2026 analysis of fan-out queries found that ChatGPT added the word “best” to 24.3% of advice-style questions even when the user had not typed it. So a buyer who asks an assistant a plain question about which tool to use may, without knowing it, set off a search for exactly this kind of page.

Peec AI studied nearly 200,000 AI responses across eight engines from September 2025 to March 2026, and three of its findings bear on this work. Holding the top rank in a cited listicle lifted brand visibility by 16.5 percentage points in B2B software. 52% of the listicles cited by ChatGPT had high citation rates, although listicles were under a fifth of cited URLs, which suggests that a list which gets cited tends to be cited again and again. And engines that cite few sources per answer, such as ChatGPT and Copilot, reward the top positions most, while Google’s AI Overviews and AI Mode cite more widely and show smaller gains per rank. That last point has a practical consequence: where an assistant draws on only a few sources, being fifth in a list may bring little, so position is worth asking about as well as inclusion.

Peec sells an AI visibility tracker, and the study is correlational. Brands at the top of lists are often the market leaders, which would lift their visibility anyway. The figures are a reason to take lists seriously, and they should not be read as a promise that moving up one place will produce a measurable gain.

Find the lists that count

Peec’s own summary is the best rule: five strong placements in lists that AI engines retrieve matter more than 50 placements in articles engines never see. So start from retrieval and work back.

  1. List your prompts. Write the questions a buyer would ask, such as “best invoicing software for freelancers”.
  2. Record what is cited. Run each prompt several times in the assistants your buyers use and note every third-party list that appears as a source. Bing Webmaster Tools shows Copilot’s grounding queries for free. Paid trackers are in the AI visibility tools comparison.
  3. Add the lists that rank. Search Google for the same phrases and for “[competitor] alternatives”. Note the lists on page one.
  4. Mark the gaps. For each list, record whether you are in it, which competitors are, and your position. A link gap analysis in a backlink tool finds lists that link to rivals and not to you.
  5. Rank the targets. Lists cited repeatedly, across several prompts, where competitors appear and you do not, come first.

The reason for running each prompt several times is that assistants do not return the same sources on every run, so a list that shows up once may be an accident while one that shows up on most runs is part of how the assistant answers that question. The result of the exercise should be a short sheet of targets, not a long one. A brand that ends up with a few dozen lists, ordered by how often each is cited, has a workable plan, whereas a spreadsheet of every “best” article in the category sends effort to pages no assistant reads.

Work out how each list is made

Lists are built in different ways, and the route in depends on which kind you are looking at.

Type of list How entries are chosen Route in
Editorial, tested A writer tries the products Product access, a clear angle, patience
Editorial, researched A writer compiles from reviews and vendor pages Accurate public facts, strong reviews, a short pitch
Affiliate The publisher earns commission on sales A programme the publisher can join. See affiliate programmes
Review platform category page Ranked by user reviews A claimed profile and real reviews. See reviews as a signal
Sponsored Positions are sold and labelled A media buy, with limited value for AI citations
Pay to play, unlabelled Positions are sold and not labelled Avoid

Read the page’s disclosure and methodology notes. Look at whether the links are affiliate links. Check when it was last updated, since a list refreshed every year has a natural moment to add you. These three checks save a wasted pitch, because the same email will not work on every row of the table. A writer who tests products wants access and time. A publisher who earns commission wants a programme to join, and no amount of product detail will move them if there is nothing to earn. A category page ranked by user reviews has no editor to persuade at all, so the work there is on the profile and the reviews.

Give the editor a reason

Peec’s recommendation is to give publishers justification: comparison data, reviews and pricing evidence that earn the inclusion. In practice that means a short email built from five things. The first is one sentence on who you are best for. Lists are organised by use case, so “best for teams under ten” is a slot, and “a great all-round tool” is not. The second is current facts: pricing, plan limits, platforms supported. Writers copy these, and stale ones are a common reason for being left out. The third is proof, which might be your rating on the review platform that matters in your category, a named customer, or independent test results.

The fourth is access, meaning a free account or a review unit, with no conditions on what is written. The fifth is a correction, where one is due. If the list already mentions you with wrong pricing or a dead link, fixing that is the easiest first contact, because you are helping the editor keep the page accurate before asking for anything. The pitch itself follows the same rules as any outreach email: short, specific to that page, and from a named person.

Ask for a link with your brand name as the anchor. If the editor adds you without a link, the mention still does its job in AI answers, and you can follow up later as you would with any unlinked mention. The order of priorities here is the reverse of ordinary link building. In a list that assistants retrieve, being named next to the category is the main prize and the link is a welcome extra.

A market exists for paid places in lists. Our research holds two price ranges, both low confidence: $200 to over $2,000 per inclusion from practitioner sources, and $49 to over $8,000 in one report on pay-per-placement PR. Treat both as rough indications. Paying is growing. In BuzzStream’s State of Digital PR 2026 survey of more than 150 practitioners, 80% said they never pay for placements, down from 87.3% in 2025. The problem is the same one that applies to paid guest posts, with an extra twist that comes from how assistants treat labelled content.

Disclosed, a paid placement is legal advertising. But paid and advertorial content was only 0.3% of AI citations in Muck Rack’s May 2026 report, a vendor figure we took from a press release. Labelled placements do little for AI visibility, so the honest version of the purchase buys reach among readers of that page and not much else. Undisclosed, it deceives the reader. Law-firm summaries of the US Federal Trade Commission’s 2023 Endorsement Guides say the FTC treats paid positions on a ranking site that presents itself as independent as deceptive. We did not find that wording on the FTC’s own guidance page. Google’s spam policies list paid links that pass ranking credit as link spam, and since 15 May 2026 they also cover attempts to manipulate generative AI responses in Google Search.

That leaves the buyer in an awkward spot. The version that is allowed appears, on the Muck Rack figure, to do little for AI citations, and the version that might be cited depends on hiding the payment from readers, regulators and search engines at once. The honest alternatives are the ones above: an affiliate relationship with disclosed commission, product access, and data that justifies the entry.

Lists you write about yourself

Many brands publish their own “best X” list and put themselves first. Peec AI analysed 232,000 citations across 13,000 software listicles from December 2025 to February 2026. Self-promotional lists made up about 11% of AI citations overall: 10.3% on Google AI Mode, 10.4% on Perplexity and 3.6% on ChatGPT. Peec saw no sign of a correction during those 12 weeks. So the tactic was being cited during the period studied, and nothing in that data showed assistants turning against it.

The downside is documented. Lily Ray reported on 3 February 2026 that several software sites lost 29% to 49% of their Google organic visibility from mid-January 2026. Common traits were between 10 and 340 self-promotional “best” lists, scaled AI content and titles refreshed with the year. She noted it was one tactic among several, and that some such lists still rank. Put the two findings side by side and the trade is clear enough: a share of AI citations on one side, and on the other a reported loss of organic visibility at sites that leaned on the pattern heavily. One honest comparison page that says who each product suits is defensible. Hundreds are a pattern.

To measure the work on other people’s lists, keep a sheet of target lists with four columns: included or not, position, link or no link, and whether the list was cited for your prompts this month. Report mention rate across many runs of those prompts, before and after. Check quarterly, since lists are updated and positions move. Lists are one output of digital PR, which is how you earn the coverage that makes editors think of you first. See the glossary for listicle, fan-out and citation.

Common questions

How do I get my product included in "best of" lists?

Find the lists that rank and get cited for your category, check how each one chooses its entries, then send the editor a short pitch with a clear reason to include you, current pricing and product access. An affiliate programme helps with lists run by affiliate publishers.

Can I pay to be included in a "best X" list?

Some publishers sell placements. A disclosed sponsored placement is legal and is rarely cited by AI assistants. An undisclosed one deceives readers, breaks advertising rules and falls within Google's spam definition.

Should I write my own "best X" list with my product first?

It can be cited in the short term, but it carries a documented risk. Lily Ray reported in February 2026 that several software sites with many such pages lost 29% to 49% of Google organic visibility from mid-January 2026, as one factor among several.

Why do AI assistants cite listicles so often?

Assistants rewrite questions into searches, and Peec AI found in 2026 that ChatGPT added the word "best" to 24.3% of advice-style questions. Those searches retrieve comparison lists, which already contain the answer in the form the assistant needs.

Does my position in the list matter?

Yes, more on some assistants than others. Peec AI found that assistants citing few sources, such as ChatGPT and Copilot, reward top positions most, while Google's AI surfaces cite more widely and show smaller gains per rank.

Vendors to look at

  • BazoomEditor's pick

    Sponsored content and link marketplace, managed service

  • MotherlinkEditor's pick

    Backlink services, guest posts, niche edits, full SEO