Types of backlinks: which ones carry weight
Backlinks differ by how they were placed, where they sit on the page and which attribute they carry. Editorial links inside the main content count most. Sitewide, bulk directory and user-generated links count least.
In short
- Google's spam policies, last updated in August 2026, name low-quality directory links, keyword-rich widget links, footer or template links and optimised forum links as link spam.
- In Ahrefs' study of one million keywords, published in January 2025, followed referring domains correlated with rankings at 0.250 and all referring domains at 0.255, so the data cannot separate followed from nofollow.
- BuzzStream's 2026 studies rated 96.2% of guest post sellers and 97.5% of link insertion offers as low quality, so the type of link tells you less than the site it sits on.
- ESBO's September 2026 analysis of 16,625 publishers found that 39% of publishers at DR 80 or more sell nofollow placements only.
- A redirect passes link value only when the old page and the new page are closely related, and Google has had a policy against expired domain abuse since March 2024.
A backlink’s type tells you three things: who decided to place it, where it sits on the page, and which attribute it carries. Those three facts predict most of its value. A link that an editor chose to add inside the body of a relevant article sits at the top. A link that anyone can create for themselves, or that repeats in a template across a whole site, sits at the bottom. Most of the names the trade uses for link types are shorthand for some combination of those three facts, so once you can sort a link on each of them, the vocabulary stops being a list to memorise. The names used below are all defined in the glossary.
Three ways to sort a backlink
The first sorting is by who placed the link. Editorial links are given by someone with a free choice. Self-created links (profiles, comments, most directories) involve no choice by anyone else. Paid and negotiated links sit in between, because a second party agreed to the link but had a reason other than the merit of the page. The second sorting is by where the link sits. In-content links sit in the main text. Sitewide links sit in a footer, sidebar or template. Image links wrap a picture, not words. The third is by attribute. A link is either followed (no attribute) or qualified with nofollow, sponsored or ugc.
These three ways of sorting are independent of one another, which is why a single link needs all three to describe it. An editorial link can be nofollow, a paid link can sit in the main text of an article, and a followed link can sit in a footer. Much of the confusion in link reports comes from using one of these facts as if it settled the other two, for instance treating “followed” as a synonym for “valuable” when the link in question was self-created on a page nobody visits.
The main types compared
Risk in the table uses this site’s R1 to R5 scale, where R1 is within Google’s guidelines and R5 is severe. The weight column gives a direction only. The research has no measured weight for any link type, so words such as “high” and “low” record where the evidence points and should not be read as quantities.
| Type | How you get it | Usual attribute | Likely weight | Risk |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Editorial (earned, digital PR) | A writer cites your data, story or expert | Followed or nofollow, the publisher decides | Highest | R1 |
| Genuine guest post | You write for a publication with editorial standards | Often followed | High when the site is real | R1 to R2 |
| Paid guest post | You pay a publisher to run an article | Followed without a label in trade use | Depends wholly on the site | R3 |
| Niche edit (link insertion) | A link is added to an existing article | Usually followed | Depends on the host page | R3 |
| Directory and local citation | You submit a listing | Mixed | Low as a ranking link | R1 curated, R3 for bulk packages |
| User-generated (forum, comment, profile) | You post it yourself | Mostly nofollow or ugc | Very low | R1 for real participation, R3 or more for spam |
| Sponsorship | You fund an event, club or project | Should be sponsored | Low to medium | R2 |
| Sitewide (footer, sidebar) | Template placement | Mixed | Low per link | R3, higher with exact-match anchors |
| Image link | Your image is used with a credit | Followed or nofollow | Similar to a text link in the same position | R1 |
| Redirect (301) | An old URL or domain points to yours | Not applicable | High if relevant, nothing if not | R2 for a real merger, R4 for unrelated domains |
| Widget or badge | Embed code carries a link | Should be nofollow | Low | R3 to R4 with keyword anchors |
| Network link (PBN, automated) | Bought or built on controlled sites | Followed | Unreliable | R4 to R5 |
Followed, nofollow, sponsored and ugc
A followed link is a plain link. The other three are qualifiers a publisher adds. Google’s guidance says sponsored is for paid placements, ugc is for forums and comments, and nofollow is for links a site does not want to vouch for. Since 2019 Google is reported to treat all three as hints, so it may still choose to use a qualified link. That matters because, under a hint model, the attribute tells Google what the publisher intended and Google keeps the decision about what to do with the link, so a qualified link cannot simply be assumed to count for nothing.
Nobody outside Google knows how often it does use one. In Ahrefs’ study of one million keywords, published in January 2025, followed referring domains correlated with rankings at 0.250 and all referring domains at 0.255. Those two numbers are too close to tell the types apart, so the data neither shows that nofollow links help nor that they do nothing. In a March 2026 survey of 518 SEOs by Editorial.link, 78.8% said they believe nofollow links affect rankings. That is a belief, not a measurement, and it is worth keeping the two apart when a vendor quotes the survey as if it were proof.
Two details matter when you buy. An Ahrefs study is reported to have found the sponsored attribute on about 0.01% of referring domains, so most paid links carry no label. If that reported figure is right, the attribute Google asks for on paid placements is close to absent from the web as it actually is. And the best publishers often refuse to sell followed links at all: ESBO’s September 2026 analysis of 16,625 publishers, reported by Entrepreneur, found 39% of publishers at DR 80 or more sell nofollow placements only. On ESBO’s figure, a buyer who insists on followed links is ruling out that 39% of the highest-rated publishers before the search begins. Our lesson on link attributes covers the detail.
Types by who placed the link
An editorial link exists because the page is better with it. Most are the result of deliberate promotion, which is what digital PR is, so “earned” should not be read as “accidental”. News coverage is often copied to partner sites, and the value of those syndicated copies is disputed: a single-site test by Reboot Online in February 2025 saw rankings rise after about 180 syndicated links, while BuzzStream’s guide treats such copies as worth little for SEO. With one test on one site set against a contrary opinion, the honest position is that syndicated copies should not be counted as if each were a separate piece of coverage, and should not be written off either.
Guest posts come in two kinds that share a name. A genuine guest post is written for a publication that rejects weak pitches. A paid guest post is an article a publisher runs for a fee. They look alike and behave differently, and the market data shows how far apart they are: BuzzStream’s June 2026 study of roughly 257,000 sellers rated 96.2% as low quality and found 39.6% had no organic traffic. A niche edit is the related case of a link added to an article that is already indexed. The value comes from the host page’s own links and traffic, not the domain’s score. BuzzStream’s August 2026 study rated 97.5% of link insertion offers as low quality. See niche edits for how to judge one. On those figures, picking a paid placement at random is very likely to buy a poor one, which is why the selection of the site matters more than the type of placement.
Directories and citations are the commonest self-placed links. A citation lists a business name, address and phone number. Practitioners treat local citations as a local pack and entity signal more than a ranking link. BrightLocal’s price in October 2026 was $2.00 to $3.20 per citation. Curated directories pass a simple test: would a customer use it, and does it reject listings? User-generated links are the other self-placed group, covering forum posts, comments, profiles and Q&A answers. Most are nofollow or ugc, and all external links on Wikipedia are nofollow. Practitioners value them for visibility and referral traffic. Forum comments with optimised links are named in Google’s spam policies, so the same forum can host a harmless link from a real participant and a policy violation from someone posting keywords.
Sponsorships sit in an awkward spot between the groups. A sponsor page linking to a funder is a paid link in the strict sense, and Google expects a qualifying attribute. Genuine sponsorships are ordinary business activity and sit at R2 on our scale. The distinction a practitioner has to hold on to is between funding something because the business wants to support it, where the link is a by-product, and funding something only because a link comes with it, where the sponsorship is a purchase under another name.
Types by where the link sits
Position on the page appears to affect value. A Google patent known as the reasonable surfer model is reported to describe links on one page passing different amounts of value depending on position, font size and how likely a reader is to click. Links in the main body come out ahead of links in boilerplate. That fits the way sitewide links behave. A footer link on 5,000 pages is still one referring domain. Ahrefs’ 2025 study found referring domains correlate with rankings slightly better than raw backlink counts, 0.255 against 0.248. The leaked Google documentation from 2024 contains a field for repeated links from the same source to the same target, which analysts read as diminishing returns. That reading is an inference. Even so, the three pieces point the same way, and a report that counts a sitewide link as thousands of backlinks is describing one relationship many times over.
Image links follow the same rules as text links with one difference. When an image is the link, Google’s link guidance is reported to use the alt text as the anchor text, so the words in the alt attribute do the describing that visible anchor text would otherwise do.
Redirects are the type where relevance decides everything. Google’s Gary Illyes is reported to have said in 2016 that 301 redirects no longer lose PageRank. The condition is relevance. Google staff have said for years, in statements reported by the trade press, that redirects to unrelated pages can be treated as soft 404s and pass nothing. Buying dropped domains to exploit their links has been a named spam policy, expired domain abuse, since March 2024. So the same mechanism covers a company moving its old domain to a new one, which is routine, and a buyer pointing an unrelated dropped domain at a sales page, which is the case the policy names. Expired domains and 301s explains the legitimate and the risky versions.
Which types carry weight
The evidence supports four rules, in direction if not in size. The first is that editorial choice beats self-placement. Google’s spam policies define link spam by intent to manipulate rankings, and every type it lists is one where nobody made an editorial choice. The second is that the page matters more than the label. The 2024 leak documents a quality bucket on each anchor tied to the index tier of the linking page. Its weight is unknown. The third is that relevance matters, which analysts infer from several leaked fields and from consistent Google guidance. The fourth is that new referring domains beat repeat links from the same site.
Put together, those rules mean a nofollow link in a national newspaper can be worth more to a business than a followed link on a site nobody reads. The type of a link is a starting point for judging it and never the whole answer. For any paid type, vetting the publisher decides the outcome far more than the name on the invoice, because “guest post” and “niche edit” describe how the link was arranged and say nothing about whether the page it sits on has readers, links of its own or a place in Google’s index.
From here, the tactics chart compares every method on cost and risk, and is the natural next step once the types are clear. For a local firm, the local business hub shows which of these types are worth the effort. If you buy placements, the link marketplaces comparison lists where each type is sold.
Common questions
What are the main types of backlinks?
By how they are placed, the main types are editorial links, guest post links, niche edits, directory and citation links, user-generated links, sponsorship links and redirects. By position, they are in-content links, sitewide links in footers or sidebars, and image links.
Which type of backlink is the most valuable?
An editorial link placed by a writer inside the main body of a relevant page that people read. The research is confident about that direction and has no reliable figures for how much more it counts than other types.
Do nofollow backlinks help SEO?
Possibly. Google is reported to have treated nofollow as a hint since 2019, which means it may choose to count a link. No public data shows how often it does, and Ahrefs' January 2025 correlation study could not separate followed from nofollow links.
Are sitewide links bad?
Not always. Links between sister brands or a branded design credit are normal. Widely distributed footer or template links are named in Google's spam policies, and a thousand links from one site still count as one referring domain.
Are directory links worth building?
Curated directories that customers use, such as trade associations and review platforms, are worth having. Packages that submit a site to hundreds of directories fall under the low-quality directory links named in Google's spam policies.

